"Ultracrepidarian: someone who has no special knowledge of a subject but who expresses an opinion about it." (Cambridge Dictionary)
A neat word coined by William Hazlitt. I found these uses of it:
1. "Like a conceited mechanic in a village alehouse, you would set down everyone who differs from you as an ignorant blockhead, and very fairly infer that anyone who is beneath yourself must be nothing. You have been well called an Ultra-Crepidarian critic." William Hazlitt, "Letter to William Gifford" (1819)
2. "In England excess in alcohol is responsible for only a very small proportion of cases of mental disease at all, in spite of ultracrepidarian views to the contrary." James R. Whitwell, letter to The English Review (March, 1929). p. 249.
3. "The Oklahoma Senate does not like what Secretary of Defense Charles E. Wilson said about the National Guard but it refused yesterday to call him 'ultracrepidarian.' A resolution had been introduced accusing Wilson of 'gross and unwarranted insult' .... Senator J. R. Hall, a Democrat, introduced an amendment which would have inserted 'ultracrepidarian.'" St. Louis Post-Dispatch (Jan. 31, 1957): 1.
4. "Now if Sino-Indo-European lexical comparison was just yet another drowsy backwater of the inveterate craze for ultracrepidarian transcontinental etymologizing, it would probably not even be justified to mention Ulenbrook's book in print." Wolfgang Behr, Review of Zum Alteurasischen. Eine Sprachvergleichung by Jan Ulenbrook, Oriens 36 (2001): 356-361, at 360.
5. "Philosophers are good at answering broadly conceptual questions of the first sort. They are no better than anyone else at answering questions of the second sort, despite their ultracrepidarian tendencies." Dudley Knowles, "Good Samaritans and Good Government," Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society New Series 112 (2012): 161-178, at p. 161.
6. "The FBI Hair Comparison Review does not seek to provide a precise and scientifically defensible estimate of the prevalence of ultracrepidarian testimony." David H. Kaye, "Ultracrepidarianism in Forensic Science: The Hair Evidence Debacle," Washington and Lee Law Review 72, no. 2 (2015): 230-257, at p. 247.
The inspiration for Hazlitt's coinage seems to lie in Naturalis Historia by Pliny the Elder, in which a painter tells a shoemaker and wannabe art critic to stick to judging shoes. This episode in Pliny gave rise to the Latin saying, "Sutor, ne ultra crepidam."
This post is derived from my Facebook post of April 8.
1 comment:
From Essays on Poetry by William Hazlitt (William Blackwood and Sons, 1901), pages 215-216:
21. note.Ultra-Crepidarian critics. The epithet—formed from the Latin proverb ne sutor ultra crepidam, “let the cobbler stick to his last”—is directed against William Gifford, editor of the ‘Quarterly Review,’ who in his youth had been apprenticed to a bootmaker. “You have been well called an UltraCrepidarian critic,” says Hazlitt in his ‘Letter to William Gifford, Esq.' (1819). In 1823, a year after the publication of this essay, Leigh Hunt brought out ‘Ultra-Crepidarius: a Satire [in verse] on William Gifford.” “The title of “Ultra Crepidarius,’” says Hunt in the preface, “which was invented for him by a friend of mine, came out of one of the humblest as well as noblest spirits that exist.” As it is improbable that Hunt here refers to Hazlitt, it would seem that both were indebted to a common source. This may have been Charles Lamb. He never forgave Gifford for editing freely a review of Wordsworth’s “Excursion' which he had contributed to the ‘Quarterly.’ In a letter to Wordsworth he says the review “in the ‘Quarterly' is a spurious one, which Mr Baviad Gifford has palmed upon it for mine. . . . The language he has altered throughout. . . . But that would have been little, putting his damn'd shoemaker phraseology (for he was a shoemaker) instead of mine, which has been tinctured with better authors than his ignorance can comprehend,” &c.; and he wrote a sonnet entitled “Saint Crispin to Mr Gifford,” which ends—
“And better to this hour you had been plying
The obsequious awl, with well-wax'd finger flying,
Than ceaseless thus to till a thankless vein :
Still teasing muses which are still denying,
Making a stretching-leather of your brain.”
Hunt's allusion to “one of the humblest as well as noblest spirits that exist” gives colour to the conjecture that the author of the epithet was Lamb. Perhaps Lamb stammered it out at one of his Wednesday evening parties. “He always made the best pun, and the best remark in the course of the evening,” says Hazlitt.
Post a Comment